A smoking ban too far

Since the early s, most states and cities have banned smoking in public indoor spaces such as bars, restaurants, and offices. These bans were sparked by contemporary research that, for the first time, proved the harmful, carcinogenic effects of secondhand smoke.

A smoking ban too far

Proposed smoking law a step too far While the good intentions of the bill are indisputable, seeking a total ban on smoking outdoors seems a step too far 03 May - No doubt he was reacting to the trend of regulating the trading and smoking of cigarettes that has squeezed the industry across the world.

In an effort to limit smoking — due to its harmful effects on public health — SA outlawed the advertising of tobacco products about 20 years ago.

Smoking ban outdoors: have activists gone too far? | National Post

Evidently that was not enough to achieve the desired effect. If passed, the new law would ban smoking in outdoor public places. It would also prohibit cigarette vending machines and, for the first time, seek to regulate e-cigarettes and other nicotine-delivery devices.

While the good intentions of the bill are indisputable, seeking a total ban on smoking outdoors seems a step too far. Laws must be just, fair, implementable and policeable.

It banned the advertising of tobacco products, regulated their sale and introduced health warnings on labels. It was a success in that it was both fair and policeable, as the retailers were directly accountable for the sale of their products.

The difference with the proposed legislation is that it seems to unfairly target smokers themselves. By seeking to ban smoking outdoors — after smokers had, rightly so, been chased outdoors by the previous legislation — the legislation would invite the kind of defiance that has killed e-tolling.

The widespread public defiance that e-tolling elicited has rendered it unenforceable. Get our news and views in your inbox As it stands, the latest anti-smoking legislation will only meet the same end.

The police already have their hands full policing real crime and failing. Smoking a cigarette is one of those "crimes" whose real victim is the "perpetrator" — the smoker. As such, criminalising smoking tobacco would join the smoking of marijuana and prostitution in the victimless categories of "crimes".

A smoking ban too far

On both those fronts, government and the ruling party have covertly conceded defeat. The high court in Cape Town has directed parliament to pass legislation to legalise "recreational" use of marijuana. This has not been opposed. At its national conference, the ANC also formally resolved to lift the criminal ban on prostitution.

Smoking bans (or smoke-free laws) are public policies, including criminal laws and occupational safety and health regulations, that prohibit tobacco smoking in workplaces and other public metin2sell.comation may also define smoking as more generally being the carrying or possessing of any lit tobacco product. May 16,  · In his article, Siegel expresses his opinion that the smoking ban in city parks and on city beaches, which becomes effective May 23 in New York City, is carrying things a little too far. And, in that at least, he's metin2sell.com: Stand FAST. While the good intentions of the bill are indisputable, seeking a total ban on smoking outdoors seems a step too far. Laws must be just, fair, implementable and policeable.

Besides, a progressive government should seek to expand, not limit, the freedoms of its citizens. Government has no business deciding when and how adults smoke. Its business, when it comes to tobacco products, is to ensure legislation regarding ingredients that go into producing tobacco is strictly adhered to.

And that all industry stakeholders pay their taxes, which should be used to pay for a proper health-care system. In this aspect, the tobacco industry has played its compulsory role, the cost of which is actually borne by the smoking public.

Turning smokers into criminals is an assault on personal liberty. It is also not the best way to treat some of your biggest tax contributors.May 26,  · Ontario's tobacco ban -- one of the toughest in North America -- takes effect May 31, prohibiting smoking in enclosed public and work spaces with few exemptions.

A smoking ban too far

metin2sell.com, a "smokers' rights" group financed by tobacco companies, says the ban will be far . Feb 08,  · OKEMOS, Mich. - Warning: Cigarette smoking may be hazardous to your job. That is what employees at Weyco, an insurance benefits administrator in this . The ban would include 1, parks, 14 miles of public beaches and all boardwalks, marinas and plazas.

This follows a ban of smoking in all the city's restaurants and bars. Open parks ban Quote Smoking could be banned in Trafalgar and Parliament squares and London parks if a report by the city's Health Commission is. Smoking bans (or smoke-free laws) are public policies, including criminal laws and occupational safety and health regulations, that prohibit tobacco smoking in workplaces and other public metin2sell.comation may also define smoking as more generally being the carrying or possessing of any lit tobacco product.

Feb 02,  · Is this taking a smoking ban too far? Local community colleges bans smoking on their campus. Ok, fine, so far. But, they ban it in ALL instances, regardless of scenario. For example: A person is not even allowed to smoke in their own vehicle with the windows rolled up while driving on a street on a remote part of campus.

New York smoking ban gone too far? Health experts disagree